The 10 Best Restaurants in Times Square: Where to Eat in NYC’s Electric Heart
Discover the diverse culinary gems—from classic diners to chic steakhouses—right within New York’s dazzling Times Square.
Times Square is often seen as New York’s bustling entertainment epicenter—flashing lights, towering billboards, and a swirl of energy that draws millions. Yet, hidden among the neon and the crowds are restaurants that both locals and adventurous visitors can savor. From time-honored classics to inventive newcomers, here is your definitive guide to the 10 best restaurants in Times Square, each offering a unique New York experience. Whether you crave an indulgent steak, authentic Latin flavors, or dazzling contemporary cuisine, these picks are sure to satisfy any palate.
1. Carmine’s Italian Restaurant
Step into the heart of Italian-American tradition at Carmine’s, a legendary family-style eatery just steps from Broadway’s theaters. Known for its generous portions and bustling atmosphere, Carmine’s brings the feel of a festive Sunday dinner every night of the week. Huge platters of pasta—think spaghetti and meatballs, chicken parmigiana, and lasagna—are designed for sharing, making it a favorite spot for both pre-show crowds and large gatherings. The restaurant’s deep red banquettes and vintage décor evoke old-school New York, while attentive servers keep the energy warm and welcoming.
- Best for: Big groups, families, and classic Italian-American comfort food.
- Signature dish: Penne alla vodka, veal saltimbocca, and the famous Titanic dessert.
- Atmosphere: Lively, celebratory, and crowd-pleasing.
2. Junior’s Restaurant & Bakery
Few pleasures are as iconic as a slice of New York cheesecake at Junior’s. This Brooklyn import has become a Times Square staple, serving classic diner fare amid glowing neon signs and a retro setting. Junior’s is beloved for its all-day breakfast, piled-high deli sandwiches, matzo ball soup, and the star attraction: their legendary, impossibly creamy cheesecake. Whether you’re seeking a quick lunch or a late-night dessert after a Broadway show, Junior’s delivers a nostalgic city experience in every bite.
- Best for: Breakfast, lunch, and a true NYC dessert pilgrimage.
- Signature dish: Classic plain cheesecake, pastrami sandwich, and egg creams.
- Atmosphere: Family-friendly, casual, and energetic.
3. Sardi’s
A hallowed name among the Broadway elite, Sardi’s is as essential to the theater district as the marquees themselves. Open since 1927, the restaurant’s caricature-lined walls celebrate decades of Broadway legends. Sardi’s is an ideal spot for theater enthusiasts seeking a little pre- or post-show glamour. The menu features classic American and continental dishes, including shrimp cocktail, steak au poivre, and baked Alaska, all served by tuxedoed waiters who carry on the tradition of old New York sophistication.
- Best for: Theatergoers and those seeking a slice of showbiz history.
- Signature dish: Lump crab cakes, Caesar salad, and famous Sardi’s burgers.
- Atmosphere: Elegant, theatrical, and rich in tradition.
4. Margon
Offering a welcome escape from the tourist crowds, Margon is a small, family-run gem with deep Dominican and Cuban roots. This West 46th Street favorite has been serving Times Square locals and stagehands since the 1970s, with a menu that stays true to its Latin heritage. Visitors can expect flavorful classics like pernil (roast pork), mangú (mashed plantains), and “los tres golpes” (the Dominican breakfast staple of salami, fried cheese, and eggs). The warm, neighborly vibe is matched by the affordable prices—a rare find in Midtown Manhattan.
- Best for: Breakfast, quick lunches, and authentic Dominican-Cuban comfort food.
- Signature dish: Pernil with rice and beans, mangú con los tres golpes, and rich cortadito coffee.
- Atmosphere: Homely, no-frills, and full of regulars.
5. The Lambs Club
Housed in a historic landmark building, The Lambs Club merges Art Deco elegance with contemporary American cuisine. Michelin-starred chef Geoffrey Zakarian curates a menu that blends the comfort of steakhouse classics with creative flair, using top-quality ingredients throughout. Highlights include dry-aged steaks, roasted chicken, and fresh seafood, accompanied by a polished cocktail program. Floor-to-ceiling windows and a red lacquered fireplace underscore the restaurant’s glamorous, clubby feel—making it a sophisticated retreat in the middle of the Times Square bustle.
- Best for: Business lunches, romantic dinners, and special occasions.
- Signature dish: The Lambs Club burger, roasted Amish chicken, classic Manhattan cocktails.
- Atmosphere: Swanky, intimate, and vintage-inspired.
6. Los Tacos No. 1
Don’t overlook Times Square’s quick eats, especially when they’re this good. Los Tacos No. 1 imports a piece of West Coast taco culture straight into Midtown, with fresh, authentic Mexican tacos that draw crowds daily. The compact menu offers a handful of options, including adobada (marinated pork), carne asada (grilled steak), and cactus. Each tortilla is made by hand, piled with flavorful fillings, and topped with zesty salsa. Stand at one of the counters, share a few tacos, and discover why this spot has legions of fans in a city famous for pizza and bagels.
- Best for: Quick lunches, casual bites, and Mexican street-food lovers.
- Signature dish: Adobada tacos, fresh guacamole, and aguas frescas.
- Atmosphere: Fast-paced, bustling, and spirited.
7. Times Square Diner & Grill
Every great New York neighborhood boasts a beloved diner, and Times Square Diner & Grill fits the bill. Open 24 hours, this modern classic serves everything from feta omelettes and Belgian waffles to burgers, wraps, and homemade soup. The bright, contemporary décor is complemented by friendly staff and a menu big enough to please picky eaters of all ages. Whether you’re craving a stack of pancakes at midnight or a traditional brunch, Times Square Diner & Grill delivers an honest-to-goodness city diner experience.
- Best for: Breakfast, late-night eats, and families.
- Signature dish: Matzo ball soup, triple stack pancakes, classic cheeseburger.
- Atmosphere: Welcoming, unpretentious, and open all night.
8. Tony’s Di Napoli
Tony’s Di Napoli offers a taste of Little Italy in the heart of Times Square. This bustling spot specializes in Southern Italian fare, served family-style for sharing. Heaping portions of chicken scarpariello, veal piccata, baked clams, and tiramisu fill the tables, creating a festive, convivial environment reminiscent of a traditional Italian Sunday dinner. The lively, welcoming staff make it a top pick for groups and those seeking a flavor-packed escape from the Midtown grind.
- Best for: Group dining, celebrations, Italian comfort food lovers.
- Signature dish: Eggplant parmigiana, linguine with clam sauce, tiramisu.
- Atmosphere: Bustling, warm, and reminiscent of an Italian trattoria.
9. The View Restaurant & Lounge
Elevate your Times Square dining experience—literally—at The View, New York City’s only rotating rooftop restaurant. Perched atop the Marriott Marquis, The View slowly revolves to offer sweeping panoramic vistas of the city skyline while you dine. The menu focuses on contemporary American cuisine with highlights like short ribs, seared scallops, and decadent chocolate desserts. At night, the glittering lights of the city make for an unforgettable dining backdrop. The lounge offers a lighter fare and a celebrated cocktail program, perfect for toasting special occasions high above the chaos below.
- Best for: Special occasions, romantic dinners, and city views.
- Signature dish: Pan-seared scallops, braised short ribs, New York cheesecake.
- Atmosphere: Sleek, modern, and literally breathtaking.
10. Virgil’s Real BBQ
Times Square might not seem like the most obvious place to find finger-licking Southern barbecue, but Virgil’s Real BBQ has stood the test of time. Housed in a sprawling, barnwood-lined space, Virgil’s delivers slow-smoked comfort with ribs, brisket, chicken, and sausage, served alongside classic sides like coleslaw, baked beans, and cornbread. The bar pours a wide selection of bourbons and craft beers, making this the go-to spot for anyone craving a down-home feast amid big-city lights.
- Best for: Casual gatherings, meat lovers, and families.
- Signature dish: Memphis-style ribs, Texas brisket, barbecue nachos.
- Atmosphere: Rustic, lively, and family-friendly.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Do these restaurants require reservations?
A: Many of the popular Times Square restaurants, especially those with family-style service or fine dining (Carmine’s, The View, Sardi’s, The Lambs Club), strongly recommend making reservations, particularly for peak times and weekends. Walk-ins are welcome at diners, Margon, and Los Tacos No. 1, but expect lines during rush hours.
Q: Are any of these restaurants suitable for vegetarians or those with dietary restrictions?
A: Yes. Most featured restaurants offer vegetarian options, and diners like Junior’s and Times Square Diner are especially accommodating. For specific allergies or strict dietary needs, it is best to call ahead.
Q: What’s the typical price range in Times Square restaurants?
A: Prices vary widely. Quick eats like Los Tacos No. 1 and Margon are budget-friendly (under $20). Mid-range diners and Italian spots average $20–$40 per entrée, while fine dining like The Lambs Club and The View can reach $50 and up for main courses.
Q: Are these restaurants kid-friendly?
A: Most, including Junior’s, Times Square Diner, Carmine’s, Tony’s Di Napoli, and Virgil’s, welcome kids and offer kid-friendly menus or meal portions.
Q: Is there a dress code?
A: Casual dress is appropriate at diners, barbecue joints, and taco spots. For upscale venues like The Lambs Club or The View, smart-casual attire is recommended (no shorts or flip-flops at dinner).
Quick Comparison Table: Times Square’s Top Restaurants
| Restaurant | Cuisine | Best For | Atmosphere |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carmine’s | Italian-American | Large groups, classic comfort | Lively, vintage, social |
| Junior’s Restaurant | Diner/American | Breakfast, casual desserts | Retro, cheerful, busy |
| Sardi’s | American/Continental | Theatergoers, tradition | Elegant, historic, theatrical |
| Margon | Dominican/Cuban | Quick breakfast/lunch | No-frills, local, welcoming |
| The Lambs Club | New American | Date night, luxury | Swanky, intimate, art deco |
| Los Tacos No. 1 | Mexican | Quick bites, tacos | Bustling, counter-style |
| Times Square Diner | American/diner | Anytime meals, families | Bright, friendly, modern |
| Tony’s Di Napoli | Italian | Celebrations, sharing | Festive, boisterous |
| The View | Contemporary American | Special occasions, city views | Modern, romantic, panoramic |
| Virgil’s Real BBQ | Southern/BBQ | Casual feasts, BBQ lovers | Rustic, fun, lively |
Tips for Dining in Times Square
- Reserve ahead: Especially for popular spots and weekends.
- Plan for crowds: Times Square is nearly always busy; allow extra time for arrivals.
- Explore side streets: Some of the most interesting food finds are tucked just off the main avenues.
- Ask locals: Don’t be shy—concierges and New Yorkers are full of helpful, up-to-date suggestions.
- Budget accordingly: Prices are higher near major tourist hubs; lunchtime and happy hour menus often offer the best deals.
For those looking to experience the essence of New York City through food, Times Square serves up an unforgettable variety of flavors, traditions, and stories. Whether you’re seeking a bite before a Broadway show or a grand meal to remember, these restaurants promise a rich, authentic taste of the Big Apple’s culinary spirit.
