11 Must-Visit Islands in New York: Escape Beyond Manhattan
Discover unique islands in New York, from urban escapes to scenic retreats and hidden gems for every traveler.
Manhattan may be New York’s most famous island, but the state is dotted with other remarkable isles that offer everything from lush green escapes to historical adventures and mouthwatering eats. Whether you seek a quick urban retreat, a day of cycling along the water, or a multi-day cultural exploration, these 11 unique New York islands provide the perfect antidote to city life. Here’s your guide to discovering the hidden and not-so-hidden gems that await just beyond the five boroughs.
1. Governor’s Island
- When to Visit: May 1 to October 31
- How to Get There: Ferries from The Battery Maritime Building (Lower Manhattan), Pier 6 in Brooklyn Bridge Park, or Atlantic Basin in Red Hook
Formerly a military base, Governor’s Island is now a vibrant oasis offering recreational, cultural, and culinary attractions for all ages. The 172-acre island is perfect for cyclists and walkers eager to explore its car-free paths, manmade hills with stellar views, public art, and ancient forts. “Slide Hill” features the city’s longest slide (57 feet), making it a hit for families. Food trucks, historical programming, and seasonal art installations dot the landscape, ensuring every visit feels fresh and novel.
- Don’t miss: Art exhibits, historic Fort Jay, and local food vendors
- Pro tip: Morning ferry rides are less crowded and offer surreal skyline views
2. Roosevelt Island
- When to Visit: All year round
- How to Get There: Roosevelt Island Tramway (Upper East Side), F train, Q102 bus, NYC Ferry (Astoria Route), or Roosevelt Island Bridge via Astoria (Queens)
Set in the East River between Manhattan and Queens, Roosevelt Island delivers tranquility just minutes from midtown. The scenic tram ride affords Instagrammable skyline vistas, while the island itself is peppered with landmarks:
- Blackwell Island Light: A picturesque lighthouse at the island’s tip offering panoramic river views.
- Renwick Ruin: The haunting remains of a 19th-century smallpox hospital—a favorite for history buffs.
- Franklin D. Roosevelt Four Freedoms Park: An architectural marvel and peaceful green retreat at the southern end.
Enjoy waterfront strolls, riverside picnics, and a variety of casual eateries—all without leaving the city.
3. City Island
- When to Visit: All year round
- How to Get There: MTA 6 train to Pelham Bay Park, then BX29 bus; car via City Island Bridge
Dubbed the “Nantucket of the Bronx,” City Island is famous for its maritime charm and seafood abundance. Quaint shops, art galleries, and colonial-era houses line the main drag, while the island’s restaurants attract foodies from all boroughs for their fresh clams, oysters, and lobster rolls. After a meal, stroll along Yacht Street for a harbor view, or explore the City Island Nautical Museum to learn about its boat-building legacy.
- Must-try eateries: The Original Crab Shanty, City Island Lobster House, Sammy’s Fish Box
4. Randalls and Wards Islands
- When to Visit: All year round
- How to Get There: Multiple pedestrian bridges from Manhattan, Bronx, and Queens, MTA subway (4/5/6 trains to 125th Street + M35 bus), or bike on greenways
Randalls Island and Wards Island are joined land masses at the intersection of Manhattan, the Bronx, and Queens. They offer an urban playground for fitness lovers and event seekers alike:
- Icahn Stadium: A world-class track and field center
- Recreational facilities: Golf, tennis, batting cages, over 60 playing fields, bikeways, and footpaths
- Major events: Electric Zoo and Governor’s Ball Music Festival
The extensive parkland and remarkable city views make this a prime spot for runners, cyclists, and anyone wanting to catch a summer concert or festival outdoors.
5. Ellis Island
- When to Visit: All year round
- How to Get There: Statue Cruises from Battery Park (NYC) or Liberty State Park (NJ)
America’s storied immigration gateway welcomes millions to trace their roots at the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration. Interactive exhibits, restored dormitories, and personal artifacts bring the immigrant experience to life. If you have ancestors who passed through Ellis Island, the research center can help you trace their journey. The ferry ride also includes stops at neighboring Liberty Island and the Statue of Liberty.
- Admission: Included with Statue of Liberty ticket
- Best for: History lovers, families, and genealogy enthusiasts
6. Liberty Island
- When to Visit: All year round
- How to Get There: Statue Cruises
Home to the iconic Statue of Liberty, Liberty Island is as much about American pride as it is about panoramic city views. Visitors can book access to the crown or pedestal (advance reservations essential), discover the Lady Liberty Museum, and stroll the landscaped grounds. It’s a bucket-list destination for first-time tourists and lifelong New Yorkers alike.
- Pro tip: Morning visits are less crowded and photograph best in the golden light
7. Little Island
- When to Visit: All year round (reservations required for peak hours and events)
- How to Get There: Walk to Pier 55 at West 13th Street in Manhattan, along the Hudson River Park
Floating above the Hudson on futuristic concrete tulip pods, Little Island is NYC’s newest public park. Its undulating landscape offers open lawns, gardens, casual food trucks, and an amphitheater with frequent live performances. Despite only being 2.4 acres, the park’s architectural whimsy and lively programming draw crowds all year. Storytelling and dance festivals are summer highlights, while sunset views from the overlook are magical any day.
- Note: Make free reservations online before visiting during peak periods.
8. Dark Island
- When to Visit: May 22 to September 5
- How to Get There: Uncle Sam Boat Tours from Alexandria Bay
In the fabled Thousand Islands region, Dark Island captivates with its mysterious Singer Castle. Built by the president of Singer Sewing Machine, the castle is a trove of secret passages, historical artifacts, and dramatic 20th-century architecture, inspired by the novel Woodstock by Sir Walter Scott. Those seeking a romantic or out-of-the-ordinary experience can even book a stay in the Royal Suite, living out medieval fantasies with a view of the St. Lawrence River.
- Tour highlight: Hidden passageways and antique collections
9. Fire Island
- When to Visit: Memorial Day through Labor Day; local businesses wind down in the off-season
- How to Get There: Ferries from Bay Shore, Patchogue, or Sayville on Long Island
A car-free escape off the southern coast of Long Island, Fire Island boasts wide beaches, vibrant LGBTQ+ communities, wild deer, and charming boardwalk villages. The varied neighborhoods—like Cherry Grove, Ocean Beach, and the more exclusive Point O’ Woods—offer everything from laid-back beach bars to upscale dining. Spend your day sunbathing, beachcombing, cycling, or climbing to the top of the Fire Island Lighthouse for sweeping Atlantic views.
- Best for: Beach lovers, families, and party seekers alike
10. Shelter Island
- When to Visit: Late spring through fall; summer is prime season
- How to Get There: Ferries from Greenport (North Fork) or North Haven (South Fork) on Long Island
Nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, Shelter Island is cherished for its peaceful small-town charm and abundance of natural beauty. The Mashomack Preserve contains 2,300 acres of protected coastal woodlands and wetlands—perfect for hiking, birding, and kayaking. Wades Beach is great for sunbathing, while the island’s B&Bs and seasonal restaurants make it ideal for quiet getaways.
- Cultural highlights: Shelter Island Historical Society, concerts at Sylvester Manor, and Saturday farmers markets
11. Heart Island
- When to Visit: Mid-May to mid-October
- How to Get There: Uncle Sam Boat Tours from Alexandria Bay; private water taxis also available
Also located in the Thousand Islands, Heart Island draws visitors with its romantic, unfinished Boldt Castle. Conceived by hotel magnate George Boldt as a tribute to his wife, the ornate structure and manicured gardens evoke Europe’s grandest estates. Tours of the castle are self-guided, and it’s a coveted spot for picturesque wedding photos and leisurely picnics.
- Insider tip: Combine with a visit to Dark Island for a full day of castle-hopping
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Which islands are easiest to access from Manhattan?
A: Governor’s Island, Roosevelt Island, Little Island, and Randalls/Wards Islands are all quickly reached by public transportation or ferry from Manhattan.
Q: Are any of these islands car-free?
A: Yes, Governor’s Island, Little Island, and Fire Island are all car-free and best explored by foot or bike.
Q: Do any islands require reservations or tickets?
A: Little Island requires reservations during busy periods; Liberty Island, Ellis Island, Boldt Castle (Heart Island), and Singer Castle (Dark Island) require ferry tickets and, for some guided tours, additional payment.
Q: What’s the best island for families?
A: Governor’s Island (for its playgrounds and programs), Fire Island (beaches and no cars), and Heart Island (castle tours) are especially family-friendly.
Q: When should I visit these islands for the best weather?
A: Most islands offer optimal weather from late spring through early fall, though Roosevelt Island, Randalls/Wards Island, and the Liberty/Ellis cluster are appealing year-round.
Quick Island Comparison Table
| Island | Main Attraction | Best Season | Access Method |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governor’s Island | Parks & Art Installations | Late Spring–Fall | Ferry |
| Roosevelt Island | Lighthouse, Parks | Year-round | Tram, Subway, Ferry |
| City Island | Seafood & Nautical Scene | Year-round | Bus, Car |
| Randalls/Wards Islands | Recreation & Festivals | Year-round | Bridge, Bus |
| Ellis Island | Immigration Museum | Year-round | Ferry |
| Liberty Island | Statue of Liberty | Year-round | Ferry |
| Little Island | Parks & Live Arts | Year-round | Walk |
| Dark Island | Singer Castle | Late Spring–Late Summer | Boat |
| Fire Island | Beaches & Nightlife | Summer | Ferry |
| Shelter Island | Nature Reserves | Spring–Autumn | Ferry |
| Heart Island | Boldt Castle | Late Spring–Early Fall | Boat |
Essential Travel Tips
- Check the seasonal schedules of ferries and attractions, as some islands have limited access outside summer months.
- Pack layers, sunscreen, and reusable water bottles—New York’s weather can shift quickly near the water.
- If visiting during popular weekends, book ferry tickets or reservations in advance (especially for Little Island and the castles).
- Consider biking to maximize your time, especially on car-free islands.
Plan Your Next Island Adventure
Whether you crave adventure, history, relaxation, or culinary delights, New York’s islands offer a dynamic alternative to city crowds and routine. From the iconic silhouette of the Statue of Liberty to secret castles and sun-baked beaches, these escapes invite you to experience a different side of the Empire State—often just a quick ferry ride away. Get ready to set sail on your next local getaway!
References
- https://www.purewow.com/travel/islands-in-new-york
- https://www.purewow.com/travel/summer-weekend-getaways-from-nyc
- https://www.purewow.com/travel/weekend-winter-getaways-nyc
- https://www.purewow.com/food/upstate-eats-trail-new-york
- https://tasterumba.com/rumba-press/
- https://www.purewow.com/food/best-caribbean-spots-nyc
- https://brooklyncandlestudio.com/blogs/brooklyn-candle-studio-press/purewow-october-2022
