Home » Lifestyle

How to Make a Tooth Fairy Pillow (With Free Template & No-Sew Option)

Craft your own magical Tooth Fairy pillow with this step-by-step guide, including sewing and no-sew techniques, plus creative embellishments.

By Sneha Tete, Integrated MA, Certified Relationship Coach

Created on Jul 9, 2025

Craft your own magical Tooth Fairy pillow with this step-by-step guide, including sewing and no-sew techniques, plus creative embellishments.

Creating a Tooth Fairy pillow is a cherished tradition for many families, offering a whimsical way to help children mark the milestone of losing their baby teeth. Whether you’re a sewing enthusiast or a DIY beginner, this guide covers everything you need: from printable patterns and step-by-step directions to creative personalizations and a no-sew alternative. All you need are a few supplies, some creativity, and a little bit of crafting time to make a magical keepsake.

Materials & Tools
Free Template Download
Cutting Your Pieces
Decorating the Tooth Fairy Face
Creating the Pocket
Making and Attaching the Wings
Assembling Your Tooth Fairy Pillow
Sew and No-Sew Finishing Options
Customization & Creative Ideas
Frequently Asked Questions

Materials & Tools

Gathering your supplies is the first step. Here’s what you’ll need for this project:

Printable Tooth Fairy Pillow Template (see below for details)
White felt or fabric (for the pillow base)
Pink felt (for cheeks and the pocket)
Glitter fabric or craft felt (for the wings and crown)
Embroidery floss or sewing thread (matching or contrasting colors)
Stuffing (polyfill, batting, or fiberfill)
Googly eyes, buttons, or black felt (for eyes)
Fabric glue (if you prefer the no-sew method)
Thin ribbon or rope (optional, for hanging)
Scissors
Needle (for sewing)
Marker or pen (to trace the template or draw the smile)
Straight pins (for assembling)

Free Template Download

Start by printing the free Tooth Fairy pillow template. Most templates include:

Tooth pillow shape (front and back)
Pocket pattern (often a semicircle or heart)
Wing shapes
Crown shape (optional)

Tip: If you do not have access to a printer, you can hand-draw a tooth shape (about 7″–8″ tall) and the other decorative pieces as needed.

Cutting Your Pieces

With your template on hand, prepare your pieces:

Trace and cut two tooth shapes from white felt or fabric—one for the front, one for the back.
Cut two cheeks from pink felt (small circles, about 1” diameter).
Cut a pocket shape from pink felt (semicircle or heart).
Cut two sets of wing shapes from glitter fabric or felt (mirror the template for left and right wings).
If using a crown, cut two crown shapes from glitter fabric or felt.

Remember: Flip your wing template horizontally to create symmetrical wings for both sides.

Decorating the Tooth Fairy Face

This is where you can add some personality to your pillow:

Cheeks: Either sew or glue the pink circles onto the front tooth piece.
Mouth: For sewists, lightly draw a smile with a thin marker and embroider along the line (“back stitch” recommended). For no-sew, simply draw the smile with a black permanent marker or use a thin black fabric paint pen. Let it dry before assembling.
Eyes: Glue on googly eyes or sew/glue on small ovals of black felt or buttons. If desired, embroider sleepy or smiling eyes for a unique expression.

Creating the Pocket

The pocket is what makes this pillow special—it’s where children tuck their lost tooth and, later, find a coin or note from the Tooth Fairy! Here’s how to create it:

Place the pink pocket piece on the back tooth piece. Center it in the upper or middle section.
Sew (or glue for no-sew) along the curved or lower edge of the pocket, leaving the top open.
Optional: Add a decorative ribbon or trim across the top of the pocket before attaching.

Making and Attaching the Wings and Crown

Give your pillow a magical look with wings (and a crown, if desired).

Preparing the Wings

Pair up your wing shapes so the glitter fabric faces out.
Glue the matching wing pairs together along the outer edges, leaving the inner straight edge unglued for attachment. Let dry.
Remember: The inner edge should be slightly wider, forming a strip for securing to the pillow.

Attaching the Wings

Lay out the back tooth piece face down.
Position the wings so the inner strip is exposed, pointing inward, with the glitter sides facing out.
Glue along the exposed strip, then set the back tooth piece on top, sandwiching the strips between layers. Let the glue dry fully. (Straight pins can help hold pieces in place as it dries.)

Optional: Adding a Crown

Glue or sew your two crown pieces together, glitter sides facing out.
Attach the crown to the top between the front and back pieces, before final sewing or gluing.

Assembling Your Tooth Fairy Pillow

Now you are ready to build the finished pillow:

With all decorations and attachments in place, stack your pieces in this order:
- Back piece with pocket and wings (and crown, if using) facing down
- Batting or stuffing in the middle (cut into a tooth shape, slightly smaller than the fabric for ease)
- Front piece with face, cheeks, and eyes facing up
If using a hanging loop, insert the ends of your ribbon or rope between the pieces at the top, so the loop will protrude once stitched.
Pin all layers together to hold everything in place.

Sew and No-Sew Finishing Options

Sewing Method

Using white thread and a needle (or sewing machine), sew around the entire edge of the pillow, maintaining a 1/4″ seam allowance.
Be sure to capture the edges of the wings and hanger ribbon in your stitching for durability.
If your pillow has tight curves, sew slowly for clean lines.
Finish by tying off the thread securely and trimming any excess.

No-Sew Method

Apply fabric glue in a thin line around the inside edge between the front and back pieces.
Press firmly together, using pins to keep pieces from shifting as the glue dries.
Once the glue is fully dry, check for any openings and reseal if needed.

Finishing Touches

Let your pillow air-dry before adding more decorations or using it.
If desired, personalize with your child’s name using iron-on letters, fabric markers, or embroidery.
Trim away any visible excess threads or glue for a neat finish.

Customization & Creative Ideas

Idea	Description
Personalize with Name	Embroider or write your child’s name on the pillow for a keepsake touch.
Colorful Fabrics	Experiment with different colors for the tooth, pocket, or wings to match your child’s style.
Fabric Paints & Markers	Decorate with extra patterns, stars, or messages using child-friendly fabric paint.
Unique Wings	Make butterfly or dragonfly wings for a magical or whimsical look.
Seasonal & Themed Pillows	Create themed pillows for holidays or your child’s favorite characters with simple felt cut-outs and motifs.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What can I use if I don’t have felt?

You can use any sturdy fabric, such as cotton, fleece, or canvas. Just be sure to finish the edges to prevent fraying, and double up thinner fabrics for durability.

How do I make the pillow washable?

Sewing is recommended for a washable pillow. Use fabric, batting, and thread that are machine-safe, and avoid fabric glue or embellishments not designed for laundering.

Can I make a pillow without a sewing machine?

Absolutely! This project can be completed with basic hand-sewing stitches or fabric glue for a no-sew option.

What should I put in the pocket besides money?

In addition to coins, consider leaving notes from the Tooth Fairy, special stickers, mini toys, or a small token to brighten your child’s day.

What if I want a larger or smaller pillow?

Scale your printable template in your printer settings or trace a larger/smaller hand-drawn design before cutting the fabric to personalize the size.

How do I attach the hanging loop securely?

If sewing, insert the ribbon or looped rope between the fabric layers at the top and stitch over it several times for reinforcement. For no-sew, apply extra fabric glue and let it cure thoroughly for strength.

Enjoy the Tooth Fairy Magic!

Making a Tooth Fairy pillow is a delightful way to celebrate childhood milestones. With endless ways to customize, add pockets, wings, faces, and names, you’ll create a keepsake your child will treasure for years. Whether you’re crafting for your own family or as a heartfelt gift, this pillow is sure to make every Tooth Fairy visit a little more special—and a lot easier!