Ranking Every Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl Cookie: A Complete Taste Test
We review and rank all six Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl cookies, offering honest opinions, flavor details, and whether these hyped desserts live up to the craze.
Kardashian-Jenner x Crumbl: Every Cookie Ranked, Reviewed, and Debated
Few dessert launches have sparked as much curiosity—and controversy—as Crumbl’s limited-edition collaboration with the Kardashian-Jenner family. From April 7th to 12th, every Crumbl location across the U.S. dedicated its rotating flavor lineup to six specialty treats honoring one member of the reality TV empire. That’s right: Kim, Khloe, Kourtney, Kris, Kendall, and Kylie each inspired a one-of-a-kind cookie or dessert—sold individually or as an iconic six-pack box.
With fans and critics alike taking to social media to celebrate (or deride) the partnership, we bought every flavor and sampled each one, with no Kardashian bias clouding our judgment. Here, we break down and rank every cookie, analyzing taste, texture, presentation, and fan reactions—so you know what you really missed (or didn’t) if you didn’t get your hands on a box.
The Crumbl x Kardashian-Jenner Collaboration: Why All the Hype?
Crumbl Cookies has built a cult following with its rotating menu, oversized cookies, and frequent forays into pop culture collaborations. Still, even by its standards, the Kardashian-Jenner collection generated massive buzz. Each treat channeled its family inspiration in both look and recipe, promising showstopping flavors and over-the-top presentation. Individual cookies ranged from $4.49 to $6.48, although fans could grab all six in a special pink signature box for $22.99.
- Each cookie or dessert was inspired by one Kardashian-Jenner member.
- Available at all U.S. Crumbl locations for one week only.
- Flavors ranged from classic crowd-pleasers to experimental health-focused bites.
- The release divided fans, receiving praise for creativity but also criticism for the partnership’s tone and execution.
Ranked: All Six Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl Cookies
Our ranking reflects flavor and texture exclusively—no Kardashian favoritism in sight. Let’s count down, from least impressive to absolute favorite.
6. Kylie’s Pink Confetti Sugar Cookie
Inspiration: Kylie Jenner | Official Description: Vibrant vanilla sugar cookie, topped with pink cake batter buttercream and rainbow sprinkles.
- Flavor Review: Expectations were high—after all, who can resist a sprinkle cookie? Unfortunately, this one underwhelms with overwhelming, one-note sweetness. The pink buttercream is pretty, but the flavor is pure sugar with little depth; a pinch of salt or some balancing acidity is sorely missed.
- Texture: Soft and slightly chewy, as you’d expect from Crumbl, but the overall experience feels flat.
- Summary: If you love super-sweet treats with a festive look, you’ll be happy. For most, this is too much sugar and too little complexity.
Ranking: 6/6 (the lowest on our list)
5. Kendall’s Chocolate Pretzel Cookie
Inspiration: Kendall Jenner | Official Description: A chocolate cookie stuffed with a creamy filling and topped with caramel and pretzel pieces.
- Flavor Review: This cookie promises salty-sweet goodness, but the flavor is muted. The bitter notes from the chocolate aren’t balanced with enough sweetness, and the caramel, while sticky, is surprisingly restrained. The pretzels add necessary crunch but quickly lose their snap.
- Texture: Dense, slightly dry; not much gooeyness. The filling feels like an afterthought rather than a star.
- Summary: Fine, but far from Crumbl’s best, and not as decadent as its inspiration.
Ranking: 5/6
4. Kris’s Classic Yellow Layer Cake
Inspiration: Kris Jenner | Official Description: A double-layered yellow cake with chocolate frosting and chocolate shavings.
- Flavor Review: Not technically a cookie, this treat is structured like a mini yellow layer cake sandwich. The cake is soft and fluffy, though the flavor is a bit plain—comparable to a standard grocery store sponge cake. The chocolate frosting is grainy and delivers most of the sweetness. Chocolate shavings on top add texture but not much complexity.
- Texture: Refreshingly light compared to other Crumbl offerings. The frosting can feel slightly gritty—less creamy than expected.
- Summary: A perfectly serviceable snack, but not truly special. More nostalgic than innovative.
Ranking: 4/6
3. Khloé’s Rolled Birthday Cake Cookie
Inspiration: Khloé Kardashian | Official Description: Soft sugar cookie rolled with birthday cake filling and sprinkles, topped with a drizzle of white chocolate.
- Flavor Review: A sweet, nostalgic treat that channels the classic “funfetti” cake experience. The birthday cake filling is gooey and rich, cut by the pop of rainbow sprinkles. The sugar cookie base is buttery but not overly dense. Some might find it a tad sweet, but it captures the spirit of a birthday bash.
- Texture: Soft, with delightful pockets of filling and a satisfying bite from sprinkles.
- Summary: A delightfully festive cookie, perfect for celebrations.
Ranking: 3/6
2. Kourtney’s Flourless Chocolate Cake Cookie
Inspiration: Kourtney Kardashian-Barker | Official Description: Gluten-friendly flourless chocolate cookie sweetened naturally with apple sauce and honey. No refined sugar.
- Flavor Review: This “cookie” is a polarizing pick—fans of clean eating give it high marks, while some dessert traditionalists argue it’s too earthy, even “like dirt” according to some viral videos. That said, the texture is reminiscent of a fudgy brownie, and the cocoa flavor is deep, with lingering richness balanced by natural sweetness. If you’re used to gluten-free or refined-sugar-free treats, this will taste like a genuine dessert; if not, expect something closer to chocolate pudding.
- Texture: Moist, dense, and dark, similar to a flourless chocolate torte.
- Summary: Not for everyone, but a bold offering that stands apart from the usual Crumbl fare. Vegan and gluten-conscious dessert lovers rejoice.
Ranking: 2/6
1. Kim’s Cinnamon Toast Cookie
Inspiration: Kim Kardashian | Official Description: Chewy snickerdoodle cookie with a white chocolate drizzle, topped with a cinnamon streusel crunch.
- Flavor Review: The top pick for our panel. Sweet, but not overwhelmingly so. Loaded with cozy, real cinnamon flavor and a crunchy streusel that perfectly offsets the chewy snickerdoodle base. The white chocolate drizzle adds creamy richness without overpowering the cookie. Evokes nostalgia with every bite and offers the most complete flavor and texture profile.
- Texture: Chewy, with crunchy bits that add interest in every bite.
- Summary: The best of the bunch—if every Crumbl creation tasted this balanced, we’d join the weekly lines too.
Ranking: 1/6 (the top of the list)
Public Hype and Backlash: Internet Reacts to the Crumbl x Kardashian Launch
It wouldn’t be a Kardashian endeavor without some viral backlash and heated opinions. Social media exploded when the partnership was announced, with critics calling it a “tone-deaf PR disaster” while fans rushed to score the limited-edition box. The internet debate only intensified as reviews rolled in:
- Kourtney’s flourless chocolate cookie polarized the most: Some called it “horrible” or “like dirt,” while others found it “not even that bad,” comparing it to chocolate pudding or praising it for being gluten- and vegan-friendly.
- Kylie’s confetti cookie looked pretty but left many tasters overwhelmed by the sugar content.
- Fans with dietary restrictions found at least one treat to sample, a rare feat in a mainstream dessert collab.
- Lines formed at Crumbl locations all week, with some flavors selling out early.
In Crumbl’s words: “Love or hate the Kardashians, you have to admit, they know how to get the people talking.”
The Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl Box: Details & Availability
- Available nationwide from April 7 to April 12.
- Each cookie’s price fluctuated based on ingredients—some costing nearly $2 more than others.
- The limited-edition pink box prominently featured the family’s signatures for ultimate collectability.
- Cookies could be purchased individually or as a box set for $22.99 to $27.97, depending on location.
All Six Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl Cookies: Comparison Table
| Family Member | Cookie Name | Description | Standout Feature | Rank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kylie Jenner | Pink Confetti Sugar Cookie | Vanilla sugar cookie, pink cake batter frosting, sprinkles | Bright, colorful, but ultra sweet | 6 |
| Kendall Jenner | Chocolate Pretzel Cookie | Chocolate cookie, creamy filling, caramel, pretzels | Salty-sweet with crunch | 5 |
| Kris Jenner | Classic Yellow Layer Cake | Yellow cake, chocolate frosting & shavings | Fluffy, nostalgic | 4 |
| Khloé Kardashian | Rolled Birthday Cake Cookie | Sugar cookie with birthday cake filling & sprinkles | Festive, gooey, celebratory | 3 |
| Kourtney Kardashian-Barker | Flourless Chocolate Cake Cookie | Gluten-friendly, sweetened with apple sauce, honey | Rich, vegan-ish, polarizing | 2 |
| Kim Kardashian | Cinnamon Toast Cookie | Snickerdoodle, white chocolate, cinnamon streusel | Cozy, balanced, chewy | 1 |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Which Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl cookie was the most popular?
A: Kim Kardashian’s Cinnamon Toast Cookie received the highest accolades for balance and flavor, selling out quickly at several locations.
Q: Were any of the cookies diet-friendly?
A: Kourtney Kardashian’s Flourless Chocolate Cake Cookie was gluten-friendly and sweetened with apple sauce and honey rather than refined sugar, catering to dietary restrictions.
Q: Can you still buy the Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl cookies?
A: No, these were limited edition and no longer available. However, Crumbl occasionally brings back popular flavors for special promotions.
Q: How much did the cookie box cost?
A: The full six-cookie box ranged from about $22.99 to $27.97, with individual cookies priced from $4.49 up to over $6 due to premium ingredients.
Q: Was there a reaction on social media?
A: Absolutely. The collab generated both excitement and strong criticism, with some fans celebrating Crumbl’s creativity, others calling the PR move tone-deaf, and many debating the flavors online.
Final Thoughts: Is the Kardashian-Jenner Crumbl Box Worth the Hype?
The Kardashian-Jenner x Crumbl box was as much an exercise in dessert drama as it was a baking experiment. Kim’s cinnamon cookie wins for sheer deliciousness and broad appeal, while Kourtney’s flourless option stands out for dietary inclusivity and bold flavor. Not every creation was a winner—some offerings were forgettable or divisive—but there’s no question they generated conversation, cravings, and a few sugar highs.
Missed out? Don’t worry. With Crumbl’s penchant for surprise returns, your favorite Kardashian-inspired cookie may just make a comeback. Until then, keep your sweet tooth ready for the next viral drop.
